Cellular immune problems are why young people can die from COVID-19

The pathway that recognizes RNA viruses like COVID-19 (ssRNA) and produces Interferon to defend against them.

One of the most disturbing problems in COVID-19 medicine care has been that a few young people have become extremely ill with this infection. While these cases are rare, they unnerve physicians because the patients have not had the chronic Illnesses that predispose most people to serious COVID-19 infections. Many of us have thought that these individuals have some type of occult genetic problem that prevents their immune system from protecting them from the virus. There is now data to back that hypothesis. 

A new paper published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) reports on four young men from two families who were hospitalized in the Netherlands with COVID-19. These two sets of brothers had severe COVID-19 infections, and the presumption was that having more than one family member with severe disease would indicate a genetic problem. One of the individuals died from his infection.

All four of the individuals were screened for genetic abnormalities by analyzing the entire coding sequence for every protein in their body (whole exome sequencing). The ability to do this analysis, relatively inexpensively and rapidly, has only recently been accomplished. Screening all the proteins of the body provides a quick method of determining if there is a single abnormality in immunity that might be associated with severe COVID-19 infection. Screening other family members, especially with the same illness, indicates if this defect is shared, providing substantiation of the likelihood it is behind the illness; in this case severe COVID-19 infection. 

The genetics of the families in the JAMA article. The individuals with COVID-19 are identified in pink, and the one’s with the gene defect are in green. The mother in family 1 was the carrier, but since women have two X chromosomes she had normal immunity.

Remarkably, all four individuals had defects in a single protein, the X-chromosomal toll-like receptor sever (TLR7) proteinThis is an innate immune signaling system that recognizes single stranded RNA (as is found in the COVID-19 virus) and stimulates the body’s cellular immunity, causing lymphocytes to produce anti-viral compounds like interferons. Each family had a different genetic abnormality, but in both families, it caused this gene not to function. Because this gene was on the X protein, each male has only one copy (only one X chromosome) so if that one gene is defective the abnormality impacts all immune function.

Patients from family 1 (F1 II-1) and family 2 (F2 II-1) produce no interferon in response to single stranded RNA (dark bars). The other individuals are controls who all produced normal amounts of interferon.

This defect significantly decreased the messenger RNA (mRNA) and therefore the amounts of several signaling proteins including IRF7IFNB1, and ISG15. The end result was decreases in production of interferon gamma (IFN-γ), an essential anti-viral protein. Family members that did not get ill with COVID-19 uniformly had normal copies of the defective gene.

There are several take home points from this finding. The first is cellular immunity is crucial to protection against COVID-19. This is important in understanding, and vaccines must generate this type of immunity to protect against COVID-19 infection. It is also interesting that different defects in this specific pathway caused severe disease given it specifically responds to single stranded RNA viruses like COVID-19. Also, since many immune genes are on the X chromosome, and males only get one copy, this may be why men are more likely to get sick and die from COVID-19.

The talk about antibody and immunity to this virus also needs to be tempered since another recent publication showed that people that don’t make significant antibodies can survive COVID-19. Because of this, evaluations of vaccines and herd immunity to OCVID-19 should be based on cellular immunity and not on antibody to the virus.

Finally, as we identify these kinds of defects, we can start screening young people (especially males) with severe COVID-19 for defective genes and treat them by giving IFN-γ as a drug. This could potentially save lives!

Published by jbakerjrblog

Immunologist, former Army MD, former head of allergy and clinical immunology at University of Michigan, vaccine developer and opinionated guy.

4 thoughts on “Cellular immune problems are why young people can die from COVID-19

  1. Interesting findings. Also what do you think of the idea that estrogen regulates ACE2 expression in lungs, and if that could be responsible for women having less severe outcomes with COVID inflections.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. No specific data around it, but an interesting hypothesis. Since so many of the immune regulatory genes are located on the X chromosome controlling for these other genetic factors would be difficult.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: